Why Your Ankle Keeps Rolling (and How to Stop It)

If your ankle keeps rolling, the most likely reason is that the first sprain was never fully rehabbed. Once the swelling goes down and walking feels normal, most people stop. But balance, calf strength, ankle range and hopping control often haven't recovered yet, and that gap is exactly where the next sprain happens. The good news: a structured exercise program can cut your risk of another sprain, and you can start it at home.

Why one sprain leads to another

A lateral ankle sprain, rolling your foot inward so the outside of the ankle takes the hit, stretches or tears the ligaments on the outside of the ankle. That part most people know. What gets missed is everything else that changes.

After a sprain, the ankle's sense of position gets worse. Your nervous system is slower to notice when the foot starts to tip, so it reacts later. The calf and the muscles on the outside of the lower leg weaken from a few weeks of limping and avoiding load. Ankle range, especially the ability to bend the ankle with your knee going forward over your toes, often stays stiff.

Put those together and you have an ankle that feels fine walking around but can't protect itself when you land awkwardly on a teammate's foot or step off a curb wrong.

This is not a small problem. The International Ankle Consortium's evidence review describes recurrence rates after lateral ankle sprain as high, and notes that a large percentage of people go on to develop chronic ankle instability: an ankle that gives way, feels weak and keeps getting re injured for years.

What the research says actually works

The best known study here is a Dutch trial of 522 athletes who had sprained an ankle in the previous two months. Everyone got usual care. Half also did an 8 week home program of balance and proprioception exercises, with no physio supervising them.

Over the next year, 22% of the athletes who did the program sprained again, compared with 33% of those who didn't. That's a 35% reduction in the risk of a repeat sprain, from a simple program done at home.

Two details stand out. First, the benefit was clearest in people whose original sprain was never treated by a health professional, which describes most weekend athletes. Second, the program worked even though nobody was watching. The key was doing it consistently for the full eight weeks, not stopping after two because the ankle felt fine.

The 5 minute ankle self test

Try these on both sides. Your good ankle is your benchmark. If the injured side is clearly worse on any of them, your rehab isn't done.

  1. Single leg balance, eyes open. Stand on one foot, hands on hips, for 30 seconds. Wobbling is normal. Putting your foot down or grabbing something is not.

  2. Single leg balance, eyes closed. Same position, eyes closed. This is much harder and is where a previously sprained ankle usually shows itself.

  3. Single leg calf raises. Rise up onto your toes on one leg, full height, at a steady pace until you can't do another good rep. Count them. The two sides should be close.

  4. Knee to wall test. Face a wall in a lunge stance, foot a few centimetres back. Keep your heel down and drive your knee to touch the wall. Slide the foot back until you can just touch. Compare the distance from toe to wall on each side.

  5. Hop test. Hop on the spot on one leg 10 times, then hop side to side over a line 10 times. Watch for pain, hesitation, or landings that are louder or less controlled than the other side.

If you fail one or more, you have a clear target. If you have pain with walking, can't take weight on the foot, or the ankle swelled badly and bruised after the injury, skip the self test and get it assessed first to rule out a fracture or a high ankle sprain.

The 5 things most ankle rehab is missing

Most people do a few ankle circles and a band exercise and call it rehab. A complete plan covers five areas:

  1. Balance. Start on a firm floor, then add eyes closed, then an unstable surface like a cushion or foam pad, then add catching a ball or turning your head.

  2. Calf strength. Single leg calf raises, bent knee calf raises and eventually loaded calf raises, until both sides match.

  3. Range. Work the knee to wall position until it matches the other side. A stiff ankle changes how you land.

  4. Hopping and landing. Progress from hopping on the spot, to forward hops, to side to side hops, then to cutting and changing direction.

  5. Time. The program that cut repeat sprains in the research ran for 8 weeks. Most people quit after two. Finishing is the treatment.

When to see a physio

A home program is a great fit for a first or second sprain that's moving in the right direction. Book an assessment if:

  1. You can't take four steps on the ankle, or the pain is right on the bone.

  2. The ankle has rolled three or more times, or gives way during normal walking.

  3. Pain or swelling is still there after a few weeks of doing the right things.

  4. You play a cutting or jumping sport and want to know you're ready before you go back.

At Ben Performance in Milton, an ankle assessment grades the sprain, screens for fractures and high ankle sprains, and measures your balance, strength, range and hopping side to side so you know exactly what's lagging. You can read more about how we treat it on our ankle sprain physiotherapy page, and about return to sport testing on our sports physiotherapy page.

Prefer to do it on your own?

If your ankle is fine for daily life but keeps rolling in sport, our 12 Week Ankle Prehab Program gives you the same strength, balance and hopping progressions we use in the clinic, with video demonstrations for every exercise and options for home or the gym. It's built to cover all five areas above, for longer than the 8 weeks used in the research. Find it with our other self guided programs.

FAQ

How long does it take to recover from an ankle sprain? It depends on the severity. A mild sprain often settles in 1 to 3 weeks, a moderate one in 3 to 6 weeks, and a severe or high ankle sprain can take 6 to 12 weeks or more. Feeling normal walking isn't the finish line; passing balance, strength and hopping tests is.

Should I wear an ankle brace? A brace or tape can be useful when you first return to sport, especially if you've sprained the same ankle more than once. It supports the ankle while you rebuild, but it doesn't replace the balance and strength work that fixes the underlying problem.

Can I keep playing with a sprained ankle? If you can walk, hop and change direction without pain or the ankle giving way, playing is often reasonable. If you're limping, can't hop on it, or it feels unstable, playing on it raises your risk of a worse sprain. Get it checked before your next game.

Do I need a referral to see a physiotherapist in Ontario? No. You can book directly with a physiotherapist in Ontario without a doctor's referral. Some insurance plans ask for one before they'll reimburse, so it's worth checking your plan.

Ready to stop rolling the same ankle?

Book an assessment and we'll test exactly what your ankle is missing and build a plan to fix it. Not sure if you need to come in? Book a free 15 minute phone consult and we'll talk it through.

Book an Assessment

Book a Free Phone Consult

This post is general information and is not a substitute for an individual assessment by a physiotherapist or physician.

Sources

  1. Hupperets MDW, Verhagen EALM, van Mechelen W. Effect of unsupervised home based proprioceptive training on recurrences of ankle sprain: randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2009;339:b2684. PEDro record

  2. Gribble PA, Bleakley CM, Caulfield BM, et al. Evidence review for the 2016 International Ankle Consortium consensus statement on the prevalence, impact and long term consequences of lateral ankle sprains. Br J Sports Med. 2016;50(24). BJSM

Next
Next

5 Strength Exercises Every Runner Should Be Doing